
Try not.
Do or Do Not.
There is no try.
Strangely enough, that Yodaism is written on our board as this week's message.
I had the pleasure of speaking with a true Jedi this last week! No really. Imagine for a moment that you have access to one person that is all-knowing. What would you ask them?? Hmm.
Well, the person that I am referring to is more of a specialists in the area of nutrition. Someone who pores over nearly every scrap of nutrition research and compiles it all for the mere mortals to read. The Jedi or lunatic, depending on how you feel about reading thousands of nutritional studies, that I am referring to is Alan Aragon. Alan publishes the Alan Aragon Research Review, which is an unbiased monthly critical analysis and application of the latest research pertaining to nutrition, exercise, and supplementation. I highly recommend you subscribe, if you crave in depth scientific nutritional information delivered in such a way that you can easily understand.
Personally, all of the info regarding nutrition can be very confusing. Even for a somewhat educated reader, there are too many studies to read and too much conflicting info to sort and filter. Magazines, books, newspapers and articles on the Internet can all very by as much as 180 degrees. How do you know which study was properly conducted and did not involve any special interests? Enter Yoda.
I am looking to expand our nutritional services at NPPT in 2010. I am always leery of nutritional claims and supplements so rather than just take matters into our own hands, I booked a consultation with Alan to get the correct, unbiased answers from the guy who reads all of the research.
Since we specialize in fat loss, most of the questions revolved around this topic.
Here is a summary of the question and answer session:
What role, if any, does pre/post workout nutrition play in fat loss?
Mostly none. Other than the slight muscle building advantage, pre/post workout nutrition benefits are overstated. It's best just to eat a normal meal within a few hours after training. Protein shakes are a convenient meal replacement, but there is no evidence to support any fat loss benefits using this strategy.
Is meal frequency relevant for fat loss?
No. There is no difference in body composition change in individuals eating as many as 17 micro meals a day as opposed others using a once meal a day strategy. It really depends on your lifestyle and what works best for you. You don't want to carry a cooler full of food around all day? No sweat. Kinda makes you wonder about the typical trainer recommendation of six small days a day doesn't it? You have to filter the info!
Is there any evidence to support fish oils directly aid in fat loss?
No, but there are just too many studies to support the health advantages of fish oils. If you don't eat fish 4 times a week, take your damn Omega's.
Is the answer to fat loss simply calories in vs calories out?
Yes. All diets work. The trick is finding a strategy that works for you at this point in time. On that note, eating a reduced calorie diet that is comprised of 25% or more of the calories coming from junk food will result in a state of malnutrition. If you are eating less than you need (the key to fat loss), you are already reducing the amount of nutrients that you are ingesting. You don't want to "waste" any calories on junk food.
Protein vs Carbs?
Not as big a deal as people make it out to be. On a reduced calorie diet, there is evidence to support that a slightly higher than normal amount of protein (1 gram per lb of target body weight) has some muscle sparing properties.
Most common nutrition mistake you see made in regards to fat loss?
People read too much of the wrong crap! There is so much bad information and misunderstood research available that people can become their own worst enemy. Hire a professional and listen to them and them only.
The strategy with which you have had the most success with fat loss?
Anything that increases compliance! Just sticking to the plan and having realistic expectations are the keys to success.
So there you have it. There are no nutritional secrets for fat loss. It all boils down to sticking with it and finding a strategy to reduce your calories.
Admittedly, I was hoping for some hidden secrets. But, I suppose that is what Jedi Masters do- tell you what you already know. Brilliant!
Rick Mayo





